Which do you like better (or do you like neither)? Look 1: Rihanna's glossy grape lips at the Gareth Pugh show

A closeup:

Look 2: Rihanna's pale lavender lips at the Balmain show

A closeup:

Sign up for Glamour.com’s Style Tips of the Week and Beauty Tip of the Day newsletters! We also discussed purple lips during New York Fashion Week, after I saw them at the Naeem Khan show. One of my backstage pics:

At that time, you had mixed reactions to the trend, from "I'd totally try it. Really pretty" (emmie7) to "It reminds me of what my lips look like after having a tasty grape popsicle" (courtsybud) to "I'm reminded of what my Mom told me in the eighties (the first & last time I wore purple lipstick): She said she saw a dead body as a kid and it had purple lips. Needless to say I couldn't remove the lipstick fast enough!" (SofiaS).
After seeing Rihanna's interpretations of the purple-lips movement, has your opinion changed at all? Are you inspired to find a purplish hue that works for you, or are you not stepping within 200 feet of this trend? Either way, which of the above two looks do you like better? Check out more Rihanna beauty and fashion adventures here!
Lady Gaga's Tangled Up in Blue (Ombre. Hair.) at VMAs 2010
December 25, 2011M.A.C. Launches Viva Glam Lip Glass in Gaga and Cindy
December 16, 2011Lady Gaga's MAC Viva Glam Tokyo Performance
November 19, 2011Lady Gaga says: 'Even Lady Gaga can be celibate' at M.A.C. Viva Glam London Launch
November 12, 2011Rihanna, Lady Gaga Bring Back The Moe Hairstyle
November 06, 2011Sephora Italy to Sell LeRock 'Butt-Sculpting' Beauty Jeans
December 22, 2011More Beauty for Men: Chanel, ChapFix and American Crew
December 09, 2011The Ultimate Summer Beauty Guide
December 02, 2011Sara Canning of 'The Vampire Diaries' Talks About Her Killer Looks
November 26, 2011Mark Teams Up With Designer Carlos Falchi to Launch Rio Beauty & Fashion Collection
November 20, 2011Makeup Artist Gina Brooke Shares Madonna's Beauty Secrets
December 29, 2011Dolce & Gabbana Lip Jewels, Straight Off the Spring 2011 Runway
December 29, 2011Beauty Trends From Milan Fashion Week Spring 2011
December 29, 2011Givenchy Goes Red for Holiday 2010 with Vintage Makeup Collection
December 29, 2011ThreeAsFour Spring 2011 - Backstage Beauty
December 28, 2011
Comments Rihanna Rocks Out With Two Shades Of Purple Lip. You Love?